Monday, July 2, 2007

Who's selling whom?

I remember fondly the days when songs on TV commercials meant an entirely different thing than they mean today. Time was, if your music appeared in a 30-second spot pitching blue jeans or beer (or wine coolers -- thank you, Bruce Willis!), you were either officially washed-up, or officially a sell-out. Or both.

But these days, hearing your song on a TV commercial can be a badge of honor for an up-and-coming band craving some national attention. Of course, big dogs looking to make a big splash have done it -- think U2 and Microsoft, Dylan and Victoria's Secret, etc. But usually, it's the edgier companies trying to reach a hipper audience that follow this route. The Fratellis were introduced to many Americans through an iPod ad featuring their song "Flathead." Volkswagen's been a big player in this game, with the likes of Elliot Smith and the Kings of Leon heard on their soundtrack in recent years.

On Friday, I was watching the FSN-Detroit feed of the Twins-Tigers game, and they dropped in a new VW spot with Wilco's "That's the Thanks I Get" as its backdrop. Apparently, it's part of an ongoing collaboration between Wilco and VW, which of course has pissed off some self-appointed purists of the rock snob world. Ah well, what are you gonna do? Tweedy's got a point -- those rehab bills aren't gonna pay themselves.

But even some entities not viewed as hip or edgy have paired their spots with excellent music. For instance, has anybody else noticed the ad for the University of Phoenix that uses the bouncy buildup to the excellent chorus of the New Pornographers' "Bleeding Heart Show"? It's a jaw-dropping song, both live and on disc, and I can't believe I heard it on a University of Phoenix ad. What's next? The Arcade Fire singing the theme for National American University?

6 comments:

Unknown said...

Totally true. Scott and I have noticed with dismay that some of our favorite indie bands are now used to hawk consumer products. It's hard to argue that having the music reach a broader audience is a bad thing, but the whole arrangement also smacks of sellout.

Case in point: Iron & Wine covering The Postal Service while M&Ms spin through a kaleidoscopic haze:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqAAKEda21E

yikes :).

PDizzle said...

Hey Heidi, good to hear from you! Yeah, there's two ways to look at all of this, but in the end, I'd rather know that some dude in Radio Free Nebraska or wherever has a chance of discovering Wilco just by watching the TeeVee. He's certainly not going to hear it on the local JACK-FM.

I wonder if Carly Simon fans felt the same way when "Anticipation" became the Heniz ketchup song.

Farris Thorne said...

Let's face it: there's a "right way" and a "wrong way" to have your song included in a commercial.

"Right ways?" My votes would go to Hem for having their Rabbit Songs track "Half Acre" playing behind that sorta-nice Liberty Mutual commercial where a small act of kindness goes full-circle. Or (gulp) even to Wilco for placing "Sky Blue Sky" behind the classy ad for the VW Eos convertible.

The "wrong way?" How bout Devo, for allowing their biggest hit to be turned into "Swiffer Good?"

Or the absolute worst jingle conversion out there today: the bastardization of one-hit wonders EMF into a jingle for Kraft Cheese... "They're Crumbelievable!" That one leaves my eardrums longing for the relief of an ice pick... ft

Farris Thorne said...

If you haven't been subjected to that last one...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFjctVBg6K8

I take no responsibility for getting this one out of the heads of those reading comments... ft

PDizzle said...

Stephen Colbert did an extended riff on "Crumbelievable" on his show awhile back. He thought it was awesome, which of course means he really thinks it sucks like the rest of us, he just wants us to think right-wing goobers think it's awesome.

You're Crumbelievable!

Big Primpin' said...

Good topic, PD, and I agree especially with Farris Thorne's take that there's a right way and a wrong way. Certainly some acts do sell out, but others get their stuff noticed via means other than public radio but without looking greedy. BTW, I've lived in three different cities in the last four years, and I've visited plenty of others over the years, and I will say that Louisville's public radio station, WFPK, is by far the best I've heard. I'm more often on the receiving end of tips about new music than giving, but WFPK introduced me to Citizen Cope and KT Tunstall before any of my peers had heard of them. Same with Tegan and Sara, Brazilian Girls, Ray Lamontaigne, a few others.

But back to music in commercials . . . for as long as I can remember, VW has been a regular in using hip music. And another carmaker, Mitsubishi, introduced those high-energy commercials about a decade ago. Remember "I See You Baby, Shakin' That Ass?" Thanks to those ads, I got turned onto Groove Armada, which was among my favorite bands for about five years after that commercial.

I see you Patrick, writin' that blog, writin' that blog.